Kel Shek
   |
Posted - 2006.05.09 08:57:00 -
[1]
1) love the drawings, very nice.
I'd say my opinion... the one that catches my eye the most is GS-01, keeps some of the megathron feel, but also very different. I don't see it as a teir 2 BC, and I think its too similar to the thron to be a teir 3 BS. but its very cool.
GS-03(especially looking at it from that angle view) would make a VERY nice hypothetical intermediate industrial ship between the Itty5/transport ships and the obelisk.
GS9 and GS10, I could handle as the Tier 2 BC very well. I like the strong whale-feeling on those. though they kinda look a little amarrian though, which I don't like so much.
GS9... ehhh, too strong on the amarr-ish feel, without enough whale-feel, I don't see that really fitting much of anywhere.
the GS-render one... I like the look. ... but not for a tier 2 BC. thats what I'd imagine like... a tech 3 or 4 Vexor looking like though. VERY clearly derived from the same origin, but signifigantly changed as well.
though I get the feeling your scale is WAY off, at least with the way its presented, I think thats almost frigate-scale, in fact I think at the scale you drew it with the little guy it would fit more as an ishkur replacement, (which IMO would be ok, an ultra-mini vexor could work with that style too)
my PERSONAL hope is that the Tier 2 BC will be more along the lines of a mini-thanatos. that large but flat sorta style... but if I couldn't have that, I'd be plenty pleased with the whale-ish styles you have on 8 and 10.
I don't have much of a opinion for a teir 3 BS... I don't mind what the official guy has for it. hard to tell without a angle view like the others though... but I don't think any of yours really fits the feel of it either.
I BELIVE this is the accurate pre-titan scale diagram....
http://dl1.eve-files.com/media/10/eve_chart-2048.png (lower left... lol)
~~~~~
To see a World in a Grain of Sand
And Heaven in a Wild Flower
Hold Infinity in the palm of your hand
And Eternity in an hour
~~William Blake |